May arrived home, and started to bring the fruits of her errands inside. Jared silently joined her in the garage, and began to help unload the trunk. After the third trip inside, Jared finally spoke.
“So, your friend Emily.”
May felt a flash of heat as she remembered the reason why she had slept so poorly last night. May was going to play dumb, “So, my friend Emily, “ she mimicked his pointless statement.
“Is she coming over today?” May didn’t know if he was hopeful or wary.
“We don’t have any plans, but I guess she could drop by,” it wouldn’t be a surprise if she did, since she would probably a) want to check up on Jared’s dream quality, and b) apologize to May again (in reality), though not really mean it. “Why do you ask?”
Jared was trying to keep his reserve, “I don’t know. It just seems like she’s been around more lately.”
May felt a burst of benevolence toward her brother, and toward Emily too. She had been unwilling to facilitate anything before, and maybe Emily was right to be chagrined at that. May knew she was getting set to be a hypocrite, with her plans for the evening involving Ethan. She could perhaps do these two a great kindness by simply speaking plainly now; she hoped doing so would produce some good karma.
“Jared, in case you were somehow unaware, Emily has had a crush on you for years.” May looked at her brother with a bit of exasperation. “There, I’ve said it. Do what you want with the knowledge.” She walked away, leaving Jared with a confused half-smile on his face.
Emily answered the phone on the first ring when May called her. She must have been expected it.
“Hello?” she sounded guarded.
May sighed at her poor friend. Fighting wouldn’t do any good, so she surrendered. “You already know what I think,” May began. “But I can’t force my opinions on you, so I think we should just leave the issue alone.” It was nice how she could know that Emily would take her meaning without need for any explanation.
“Thanks May,” she sounded relieved, “But I do want to apologize for going behind your back and all that.” Emily trailed off, it was plain to May that she wanted to ask how Jared was this morning, but was afraid of trying May’s patience.
“Jared asked about you this morning,” May offered.
There was a small gasp on the other line, “He did? What did you say?”
“I didn’t think you’d mind, so I told him that you have a crush on him.” May paused, “Do you mind?”
There was a silence, then an exclamation, “That depends on what he said!”
“He didn’t say anything,” I didn’t give him a chance to, “but he did smile. So, take from that what you will. And with that, I have said all I can bear to on the topic!” May brought the subject to a close.
“You are the best friend ever,” came the appreciative reply.
Not long after the phone call with Emily, Ethan called May to firm up their evening plans. It was him who suggested that they go to his house.
“Your brother hates me,” was Ethan’s argument. Bulletproof as he carried himself, he wasn’t a sucker for punishment.
“Yep.” May wasn’t in the habit of maintaining illusions for Ethan’s benefit. “Your places it is.”
Upon hanging up, she caught herself dancing a bit as she made her way to her room. Crap. She was doing just what she knew she shouldn’t, and it could only amount to emotional self-mutilation. Her obvious weakness and inability to maintain a steady course in either direction was maddening.
Here is how she knew the romance between them was born out of the reflective magic of the mirror: She loved him more than reason allowed. And for the way she felt like a truck had backed over her when there was the slightest amount of disharmony, she was beginning to absolutely hate him. It wasn’t his fault that he had this power over her; but it was easier to hate the person who sponsored her wretched feelings than the inanimate object that was actually to blame. Though she was completely inexperienced in matters of the heart, such extremes of passion were surely unnatural.
When she met up with Ethan that night, she would give him a lecture that would be as much for her benefit as his. There could be no blurring of lines between friendship and ownership of each other. She would lay down the law, lest he have any plans to try and win her over.
Her bed was still calling to her, so May curled up to sleep the rest of the morning away. She rose groggily at lunchtime, when she secured permission to borrow her dad’s car again this evening to go to Ethan’s house. It would be too date-like if he came and picked her up.
The rest of the afternoon was spent on homework, which she finally caught up on. She felt proud of herself for getting it all done, and it would leave her with a very relaxing Sunday. Soon it was time to leave for Ethan’s, she did a quick check in the mirror before taking a deep breath and heading out the door.
“Hey!” Ethan greeted her at his door with an enthusiastic grin, “Come in!”
The warmth that spread through her at his smile triggered a pep talk for herself that came out as a thinly veiled rant.
“I want you to understand that I am only here as a friend, and if you flirt with me,” May held up one finger, “sit too close to me,” another finger; “or do any other thing designed to make me want you,” another; “I will just go home.”
Ethan froze, eyebrows raised in surprise at her incongruous speech.
May instantly felt embarrassed for her outburst. “And, uh… Hi! Thanks for having me!” She turned her voice to chipper.
He smiled at her shift to normalcy, but still responded, “Don’t worry, I’ll be on my best behavior. Besides, we have a chaperone,” He threw his hands up in anticipation of her protest at the implications behind a chaperone. “Not that we need one; that’s just to say, my mom is home tonight.”
At her mention, she emerged from the background. “Ethan, don’t leave your friend just standing out there, invite her in!”
“I’m trying, Mom!” he instantly turned into the teenaged boy addressing his mother.
May stepped in and got a better look at her. But for Ethan’s transformation, she would not have guessed this woman could be his mother. She had expected a woman in her mid-thirties, and May supposed that is how old Ethan’s mom must be, but she looked even younger. The woman was very pretty, and dressed as though she still shopped in the Junior’s section. That isn’t to say she looked ridiculous, as some women who don’t know the fashion limits of their age do; she was just very youthful. For a reason May couldn’t quite pinpoint, this mother’s attractiveness made her intimidating.
“May, this is my Mom,” Ethan made a cursory introduction. May had never seen him uncomfortable before, but he clearly was now.
“Very nice to meet you, May. You can call me Tammy.” Tammy shook May’s hand, but looked on her with suspicion. “Honey,” she addressed Ethan now, “I need you to run out to my car and get my phone charger, please.”
Ethan was obedient, and May was left in the awkward position of still being eyed by Tammy, the overprotective too-young mother hen.
“So, May. You are a friend of my Ethan’s?” May could clearly sense that Tammy was feeling out the depth of this relationship. The question was not meant to be friendly, she was staking her territory. May was all at once very glad that she was not Ethan’s girlfriend, and she could answer honestly.
“Yes. We have known each other since elementary school, actually.” May felt the need to establish herself.
“Oh, is that so? I just don’t remember him ever mentioning you, I thought you must be new!” She said the words as though they were meant innocently, but May was observant enough to understand that they were meant to cut. It didn’t bother May that Ethan had never mentioned her; in the same situation with a jealous mother like this, May wouldn’t have said anything either.
“No, not new,” May made herself sound friendly. “We-- that is, Ethan, Ryan, and me-- have a class together this year and we have been hanging out more lately. The three of us.” Maybe including Ryan in the scenario would make Tammy back off a bit.
It did. Tammy instantly warmed, “My nephew, Ryan?” she beamed, “Oh, he is such a good boy, isn’t he?” A look of understanding flashed across her face, as she threw up her hands as though to pause the conversation. May had seen Ethan do the exact thing when talking to her, and the resemblance was a little shocking.
“Hold on, I do know who you are!” Tammy had shifted her take on May and was now behaving like she was one of her girlfriends. “You went out with my Ryan last night, didn’t you?”
Why was everybody hers, May wondered. And how did she know about last night with Ryan?
“Yes, like I said, Ryan is a friend, too.” May didn’t dislike a lot of people, but she was really beginning to dislike Tammy.
“You’re probably wondering how I knew about that, aren’t you?” she looked proud of herself for her omniscience.
“I’m guessing he told his mom and she told you?” May bristled against people who acted like they knew her when they clearly didn’t, and was unwilling to make Tammy’s feat of knowledge appear impressive.
Tammy looked like she was about to dig in and try to get May to dish about her ‘nephew,’ but Ethan mercifully came back in, charger in hand.
“Oh, don’t fold the cord like that, Ethan! You’ll ruin it!” his mother hopped up and snatched the cord from him, fussing with it as she left the room.
May couldn’t see how he had done anything wrong, and with her immediate distaste for Tammy, she felt the urge to contradict his chastisement and comfort Ethan; but then she saw that he was unphased.
“Ready to hit the kitchen?” he asked, excitement in his eyes.
“Do you cook a lot?”
“I do, actually! It’s another one of my deep, dark secrets.”
“Flower arrangements and cooking.” May shook her head in surprise. “You are so domesticated!”
“Do you ever cook?” He asked her in return.
“Not really. I think I’d be capable enough, if I ever needed to; but my mom is so crazy. She plans our meals a month in advance and they are always prepared and frozen like a week ahead of time.” She shrugged and offered, “So, I’m really good at re-heating.”
Ethan became a culinary instructor, showing her his method of doing things, and praising her efforts as she followed his instructions. They were making fried chicken; he claimed he had the Colonel’s recipe practically cracked. He never touched her though they worked closely together at the counter. Even when directing her in de-boning the chicken breast, he only mimicked the actions for her to follow and ghosted his hands over hers.
She had thought that any contact between them would cause her defenses to crumble, but now she thought this careful non-contact might actually be worse. He was so near to her, she could easily shift her weight and be leaning into him for a casual snuggle. One twist of her wrist would put their hands touching. It was just so tempting. But Ethan kept his word, and he was behaving; he did nothing to encourage her longings.
Tammy’s random wanderings in and out of the kitchen served to restrain May when she thought she was about to crack. Each time she passed, she sniped at Ethan for something new. “Oh, I hate it when you cook with oil. I can’t get the smell out of the house for days!”; “Don’t put hot pans on the counters!” (Even though he was clearly using hot pads); “Did you mess with the thermostat again? I’ve told you not to touch it!”
May was beginning to wonder if Ethan’s mom ever spoke to him at all if not to nag. It didn’t seem to bother him, but it really bothered May.
When they were taking their food out to the back patio to eat, Tammy called after them, “Ethan! Don’t leave a mess out there, I don’t want any wild animals coming around.” It wasn’t a horrible thing to request, but it was the last straw for May.
Once they were alone outside she could finally exclaim, “Holy crap, Ethan! Does your mom ever stop?”
“Stop what?” Ethan was genuinely unaware of any problem.
“The whole time I’ve been here, she is constantly on you for one thing or another. Doesn’t it drive you crazy? She’s not even talking to me, and it was making me nuts!”
“She’s just being a mom,” Ethan defended her casually. “Doesn’t your mom tell you what to do?”
“If I’ve done something wrong, she tells me, yeah… but your mom corrects you when you aren’t even doing anything wrong. And she doesn’t give you a chance to do something right before she tells you how to do it.”
“Well, you’ve been around her for all of one hour, so…” Ethan began kindly and trailed off. If he had finished his sentence, it probably wouldn’t have sounded as nice.
May caught the message that she was going down a bad path, so back pedaled. “Yeah, you’re right. Sorry, I should mind my own business. Hey!” she exclaimed suddenly, in order to unavoidably change the subject, “I think you are right about having cracked the secret recipe; this is amazing!”
“Thanks!” He smiled big, “You actually did most of it yourself, so now you can tell people you know how to cook.”
They finished their meal, and sat back in the comfortable patio chairs, still talking as the sky grew darker. It had been another unseasonably warm day, but now that the sun was gone, the air quickly chilled. May hadn’t brought a jacket, and borrowing something that smelled like Ethan would be out of the question.
“Well, I think I need to get going, now.”
Ethan looked disappointed, but didn’t try to argue. “Alright. Did you have fun?”
May reflected on the evening, and excepting his awkward mother and her own struggle to keep herself platonic, she had had a fantastic time. Ethan was witty and charming as ever, and the conversation and activity were awesome.
“Yeah, I had a great time with you tonight. Thanks for suggesting it.” It really did beat sitting at home trying not to think about him.
“So, please don’t get mad at me,” Ethan began cautiously, “but I just have to ask. You like being with me, so why did you decide you don’t want to date me?”
May couldn’t very well answer, “I only like you because I was messing with a voo-doo mirror,” so she became avoidant. “You didn’t want to date me either.”
“Is that why? Because you thought I didn’t want to?”
“Yes. And no.” May was becoming flustered, “Ethan, I don’t want to talk about this.”
“I know, I know, I know,” he threw up his hands in the move that now made her think of his mother. “I just have to state for the record, that I always liked you, and I always wanted to date you. You are kind and smart and cute and fun, and I was just… I had to reconcile some things first.”
Hearing him say these things was not helping her to heal from the damage the mirror caused. She closed her eyes to focus, because looking at his handsome face as he confessed his admiration for her was more than a girl should be called upon to endure.
He continued while he could, rambling, “It was hard for me to believe that you would like me too. I can see I screwed things up pretty big along the way, and now you don’t anymore, and I’m just really, really sorry. I guess your good opinion once lost is gone forever.”
May opened her eyes and looked at him, squinting, “You stole that line from Pride and Prejudice.”
Ethan paused, waiting to see if she was going to say anything else. She wasn’t. “My mom made me watch it,” he finally confessed.
“Flowers, cooking, Jane Austen… and yet you seem so manly.” May teased, trying to steer the conversation away from matters of the heart. “Don’t worry, I won’t tell.”
The breeze picked up, and caused them both to shiver. “Alright, alright, I’ll let you leave now,” Ethan playfully herded her toward her car. “Goodnight!”
“Bye, bye,” she waved as she drove away.
Meeting his mother made May feel as though she knew Ethan on a different level now. Just as Ryan had indicated to her the day he told her about Ethan’s family, seeing how his mom was cast clarity on Ethan’s personality. This was a problem because she could see that Ethan’s virtues persisted in spite of his upbringing, not because of it. How could he be such a happy, kind sort of person when at home he was constantly harangued and anyone trying to form an intimacy was shooed off? It was no wonder he sought so much female adoration at school. May was certain Ethan could only improve upon close association with a female who would encourage and compliment him.
He clearly wanted May to be that female, she now understood. May didn’t think highly enough of herself to truly think that Ethan would like her much without the help of the mirror. He had said he had “always” liked her, but what did that mean? Even if she took that to mean that he liked her like this in the pre-mirror era, what about her? She didn’t feel the same way before. When things got back to normal, she would be back to her old motto about him, which had been, basically, “Ethan: take him or leave him, though it is so much more fun to take him.” She had enough real affection and pity for him now that if she couldn’t do it for her own sanity, she could keep things platonic so as to not break his heart.
May had never been one to eat her feelings, but she drove home craving to eat something that might give her a stomachache.